It’s no secret. I did not collect baseball cards between 2004-2014 and I casually followed baseball during that time. But when I got serious about my card collecting again I got caught up on things. I recall learning that Donnie Baseball was not in the Baseball Hall of Fame. I remember my displeasure as I released a frowning “WHAT!?” followed by this surprised, drawn out statement, “UN-BE-LIE-VABLE!”
I wondered did I miss something? Was he part of the PED scandal? No, he was not. Well did the BBWAA not watch baseball in the 1980’s? I mean really! This man was one of the best ball players of the game. Do they not know that in 7,003 career at bats he only struck out 444 times? Or that he led the league in doubles for three straight years? Do they not know that he was a 6x All-Star, 9x Gold Glover, 3x Silver Slugger, and the 1985 AL MVP? In case your wondering about his fielding check this out, Don Mattingly finished his career with the highest Fielding Percentage in MLB history for any position at .992% – that’s amazing!
Perhaps it was his numbers that didn’t meet the standard. His career stat line reads: 2,153 Hits, 222 Homeruns, 1,099 RBI’s and a lifetime .307 batting average. Not to shabby in my opinion. Well perhaps it was his character flaws on and off the field? His plaque for Monument Park at Yankee Stadium says,
“A humble man of grace and dignity, a captain who led by example, proud of the pinstripe tradition and dedicated to the pursuit of excellence, a Yankee forever.”
In my opinion, looking at the fourteen year career and the delay of his entry a bit closer the circumstances were these: between 1984 and the first 102 games of the 1990 season Don Mattingly was an MVP caliber type player. In 1990, he suffered from severe back problems, missed sixty games of the season and never fully recovered. He came back and was productive, I would even say above average, but not like Donnie pre-back injury. So the the first half of his career top of the class, second half of his career not the same. So I guess it boils down to how you view it, what half of his career are you looking at? For me. I grew up watching him play and I remember him at his peak and still can’t believe he’s not in Cooperstown. My shock was echoed a couple of weeks ago because I was confident the Veteran’s Committee was going to vote him in for the 2018 inductions and they did not! Some day Donnie. You’re day is coming.
ROOKIE CARDS OF HALL OF FAMER DON MATTINGLY
1984 Donruss, Card No. 248 (shop eBay)
We start with Donnie Baseball’s best rookie card. There are several factors for this: Donruss in its fourth year of card production appears to have been striving for excellence as their sets improved year after year and the collecting community proclaimed that this was the best set of the “Big 3” (Donruss, Fleer, Topps) in 1984. Big strides were made in photography; card design was crisp with four swooshing yellow lines showing players team. The card backs were typical Donruss design however the spearmint green was refreshingly different. The primary hook is in its print production, rumored to be printed in much fewer numbers then the 1981-1983 sets.
As of the date of this post raw cards sell for $10.00 – $20.00; graded mint copies (9’s) sell between $40.00 – $80.00 and gem mint copies (10’s) sell in the $480.00 – $660.00 range.
1884 Fleer, Card No. 131 (shop eBay)
The 1984 Fleer set is considered a collector favorite. It’s an informal, laid back, fun set and just like Donruss they started manufacturing cards in 1981. Fleer also progressed their product design in 1984 especially in the photography, some of the photos are so fun-natured one questions if its even a baseball card. For example card #182 of Atlanta’s second baseman Glenn Hubbard shows him with a real, extremely large, boa constrictor wrapped around his shoulders. Okay back to Donnie Baseball. Card front shows Don in an action photo, blue stripe at top and bottom of card. Full color team emblem at lower right gives the card balance. The card backs give us a disappointing black and white photo in the upper right hand corner and the player bio is placed at the bottom of the card, kinda odd. Great stats giving collectors Donnie’s minor league numbers and a trivia question to take up that dead space.
As of the date of this post raw copies can be purchased for $2.00-$10.00; graded mint copies (9’s) sell for $15.00-$30.00 and gem mint copies (10’s) sell in the $100.00-$135.00 range.
1984 Topps, Card No. 8 (shop eBay)
Early on many collectors didn’t like the design of the 1984 Topps. Apparently, the big block team letters was one reason and allegations that it mimicked the 1983 set too much with its big action photo and a smaller portrait photo added to the front of the card was the other reason. But as time went on the 84 Topps set began to gain momentum with collectors. My personal opinion? I love it. This rookie card of Hall of Famer Don Mattingly screams classic Topps nostalgia for me. I remember rippin-packs of this stuff and even pulling this specific card which has always been one of the highlights of this set. We would bust packs open with the anticipation of pulling this card. The card backs are definitely different with its reddish/purple color. I really appreciate that it gives us full minor league and pro stats. Of course full player bio and a couple of highlights from the previous season complete this great card.
As of the date of this post raw copies can be purchased for $2.00-$5.00; graded mint copies (9’s) sell between $15.00-$30.00 and gem mint copies (10’s) sell in the $110.00-$150.00 range.
1984 O-Pee-Chee, Card No. 8 (shop eBay)
The best way to describe this one, it is an abridged version of the 1984 Topps set, with some differences of course. Card design at first glance mimics the American Topps version quite a bit but as Rafiki in the movie Lion King would say, “look harder” and you will notice: the primary difference is in number of cards with 396 cards as opposed to 792 cards in the Topps set. O-Pee-Chee is the Canadian version of Topps and primarily depicted full 25 man rosters of the late Toronto Blue Jays and Montreal Expos of course, which were former Canadian MLB franchises. The remainder of the set only depicted partial rosters of the remaining teams. Also, notice wherever the name Topps was at, is now replaced with O-Pee-Chee and the card back wherever applicable is bilingual giving us english and french translations of whatever is said.
As of the date of this post raw copies sell for $3.00-$8.00; graded mint copies (9’s) sell between $20.00-$35.00 and gem mint copies (10’s) sell in the $375.00-$500.00 range.
“Biographies-Don Mattingly.” Digital Image. PeopleQuiz – Biographies – Don Mattingly. (Accessed December 3, 2017) http://www.peoplequiz.com/biographies-34095 Don_Mattingly.html
Contributing Authors: Owens, Tom; Ellingbowe, Steven; Taylor, Ted; Lemke, Robert. Great Book of Baseball Cards. Lincolnwood, Illinois: Publications International, Ltd. 1989
Wikipedia contributors, “Don Mattingly,” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Don_Mattingly&oldid=812846874 (accessed December 9, 2017)
Don Mattingly Stats | Baseball Reference. https://www.baseball-reference.com/players/m/mattido01.shtml (Accessed December 3, 2017)